When I say things along those lines on physical circles or on reddit I get attacked or downvoted. Whether it is conservatives (pro-capitalists), pseudo-progressive-ecological-reformers, or radicals (leninists-anarchists), it makes no difference. Physics can not contradict their myth and assumptions. They exist within the assumption that if you can conceive something it is possible.
On the other hand, in the academic world, it is very rare for a physicist to make such a lecture, and not be considered a charlatan, because he is not a specialist on anything, "therefore he can not possibly know". Academics have broken down gradually into micro-specialists. A nuclear engineer can not lecture on drinking water, an economist can not speak of energy transformation, a chemist can not speak of agricultural production. But the farmer knows. The farmer witnesses the land's degradation and its inability to produce any food for any life form. The fisherman knows it takes more and more oil to produce fish. The miner knows it takes more and more digging to produce a mineral. The lumberjack knows that real good wood doesn't exist anymore and none is growing. But we must listen to the experts and obey their decisions.
At the end he says "we must reorganize society" like people are puppets in the hands of the social designers. A micro-fascist scientist nevertheless, who will impress the audience and be elected to head the department/ministry of energy someday.
How could an intelligent man who really believes what he says be so wealthy to waste money on the apple in front of him? It is a rotten apple.
John Lydon lectures on sociology, psychology, neurology, fuckallogy ... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6RPvfJXh-n0
Imagine me, with a baseball bat, walking into the distrowatch servers
On the other hand, in the academic world, it is very rare for a physicist to make such a lecture, and not be considered a charlatan, because he is not a specialist on anything, "therefore he can not possibly know". Academics have broken down gradually into micro-specialists. A nuclear engineer can not lecture on drinking water, an economist can not speak of energy transformation, a chemist can not speak of agricultural production. But the farmer knows. The farmer witnesses the land's degradation and its inability to produce any food for any life form. The fisherman knows it takes more and more oil to produce fish. The miner knows it takes more and more digging to produce a mineral. The lumberjack knows that real good wood doesn't exist anymore and none is growing. But we must listen to the experts and obey their decisions.
At the end he says "we must reorganize society" like people are puppets in the hands of the social designers. A micro-fascist scientist nevertheless, who will impress the audience and be elected to head the department/ministry of energy someday.
How could an intelligent man who really believes what he says be so wealthy to waste money on the apple in front of him? It is a rotten apple.
John Lydon lectures on sociology, psychology, neurology, fuckallogy ... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6RPvfJXh-n0
Imagine me, with a baseball bat, walking into the distrowatch servers